Top 10 Hotels in Montauk

What is the nicest hotel in Montauk and what is the best rated hotel in Montauk? Raveable's top ten collection of hotels in Montauk is designed to answer these questions when searching for the nicest and highest rated accommodation. The top 10 hotels in Montauk list reflects not only the best hotels but also the top rated boutiques and most recommended resorts. View the list below and find the top hotel in Montauk, New York based on millions of guest opinions!

Filter Top 10 Hotels in Montauk

all 10 hotels | Sort by:

 

Special Features

  • 1
  • 4
  • 2
  • 2
… More Features

Must Haves

  • 6
  • 3
  • 1
  • 1
… More Must Haves

Hotel Class

  • 1

Montauk Bed Bugs Watch

0%

Lower Risk of Bed Bugs in Montauk Hotels

Our records show low bed bug activity at Montauk hotels. Help fight bed bugs by reporting any incidents. Use these useful tips to prevent bed bugs from spreading.

Write a Bed bug Report

More Hotels in Montauk

Popular Searches:

Points of Interest:

  • Hither Huills State Park

Quick Search Montauk Hotels:

Ocean Resort Inn

1
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
1st
Good
Ocean Resort Inn
based on 124 hotel reviews
Guests of Ocean Resort Inn liked the immaculately clean rooms, the convenient location and the above average service.
Ranked #1 of 10 Best Hotels in Montauk
Pros: Soaking Tub and Romantic Atmosphere

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Hartmans Briney Breezes Motel

2
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
2nd
Good
Hartmans Briney Breezes Motel
based on 210 hotel reviews
Verdict: Good Quality Hotel
The Hartman’s Briney Breezes Motel is universally acclaimed as one of the top hotels in Montauk, New York. It is perfectly situated just steps away from the city’s spectacular beaches. Guests describe their rooms as clean, spac...  more
Great for a romantic escape with a loved one

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Harborside Resort Motel

3
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
3rd
Good
Harborside Resort Motel
based on 57 hotel reviews
Ranked #3 of 10 Best Hotels in Montauk
Guests of Harborside Resort Motel liked the very nice swimming pool, the immaculately clean rooms and the attentive and courteous staff.
Thumbs up to the Hotel Clean Rooms and Service

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Panoramic View

4
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
4th
Good
Panoramic View
based on 63 hotel reviews
“It has a pool, balcony with top view panaromic views of the ocean, just breathtaking.. private be...”  Yahoo! Travel
Bottom line: Good Quality Hotel
Bravo to the Hotel Balcony and Kitchen

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Beach Plum Resort

5
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
5th
Good
Beach Plum Resort
based on 32 hotel reviews
Guests of Beach Plum Resort liked the excellent location.
Prior guests appreciated the Hotel Kitchenette and Location
Bottom line: Good Quality Hotel

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Montauk Beachcomber Resort Hotel

6
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
6th
Good
Montauk Beachcomber Resort Hotel
based on 41 hotel reviews
Prior guests appreciated the Hotel Terrace and Heated Pool
Guests of Montauk Beachcomber Resort Hotel liked the clean pool and the location. Yet, they disliked the worn and tired rooms.
Bottom line: Good Quality Hotel

find lowest price
or book with
Expedia.com
Nearby Hotels

Surf Club Resort

7
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
7th
Good
Surf Club Resort
based on 31 hotel reviews
Hotel Kiddie Pool and Kitchenette gets high marks
Bottom line: Good Quality Hotel
Cons: Hotel Tired Rooms and Service

find lowest price
or book with
Expedia.com
Nearby Hotels

Ocean Surf Resort

8
Area: Suffolk County
8th
Good
Ocean Surf Resort
based on 37 hotel reviews
Hotel Dirty Rooms was criticized in the reviews
Hotel Terrace and Location were applauded in many reviews
Ranked #8 of 10 Best Hotels in Montauk

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels

Sun N Sound

9
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
9th
Good
Sun N Sound
based on 17 hotel reviews
Bottom line: Good Quality Hotel

find lowest price
or book with
Expedia.com
Nearby Hotels

Lido Resort Motel

10
Area: 11954, Suffolk County
10th
Average
Lido Resort Motel
based on 20 hotel reviews
Guests of Lido Resort Motel liked the exceptional staff service.
Verdict: Average Quality Hotel
Highlights include: Hotel Service

find lowest price
Nearby Hotels