Romantic Hotels in Sanibel Island

Sanibel, Florida is located directly off the Gulf of Mexico and is internationally known for its beaches; especially its many seashells and beautiful sand. One of the beaches in Sanibel is the Lighthouse Beach, known for its lighthouse. Besides the Sanibel Lighthouse, the beach offers a fishing pier to walk hand-in-hand down or to go fishing. The nature trails of Lighthouse Beach are ideal to hike with that special someone. Strolling through a museum is a way to spend the day, especially if its at the Sanibel Historical Village and Museum. This museum revolves around the history of the land and offers visitors live presentations, photographs and other types of exhibits. The J.N. Darling National Wildlife Refuge houses exotic birds on one-third of the island.

Filter Romantic Hotels in Sanibel Island

all 10 hotels | Sort by 

Special Features

  • 2
  • 8
  • 8
  • 9
… More Features

Must Haves

  • 10
  • 5
  • 4
  • 1
… More Must Haves

Hotel Class

  • 7
  • 1
  • 1

More Hotels in Sanibel Island

Popular Searches:

Check Sanibel Island Hotel Deals:


Song of The Sea

1
863 E. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
1st
Romantic
Song of The Sea
View More Photos
based on 292 hotel reviews
Hotel Terrace and Kitchenette were praised by other guests
Bottom line: Good Quality at a Good Bang for Your Buck
Great for a romantic escape with a loved one

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Island Inn

2
3111 West Gulf Drive, Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
2nd
Romantic
Island Inn
View More Photos
based on 313 hotel reviews
Hotel Location and Clean Rooms are definite plus
Great for a romantic escape with a loved one

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Seaside Inn

3
541 E. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
3rd
Romantic
Seaside Inn
View More Photos
based on 361 hotel reviews
Save money with the Free Breakfast
Popular for a family vacation

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

West Wind Inn

4
3345 W. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
4th
Romantic
West Wind Inn
View More Photos
based on 381 hotel reviews
Reviewers ranted about the Hotel Small Rooms and Lack of Room Amenities
Guests of West Wind Inn liked the exceptional staff service, the immaculately clean rooms, the very nice swimming pool and the convenient location. Yet, they disliked the missing or dysfunctional amenities in the rooms and the ...  more
Bottom line: Average Quality at a Great Bang for Your Buck

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Waterside Inn on The Beach

5
3033 W. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
5th
Romantic
Waterside Inn on The Beach
View More Photos
based on 158 hotel reviews
Verdict: Average Quality at an Average Bang for Your Buck
Guests of Waterside Inn on The Beach liked the convenient location and the accommodating staff. Yet, they disliked the lacking and sometimes broken room amenities, the comfortless beds, the compact rooms and the dingy rooms.
Hotel Dirty Rooms and Uncomfortable Beds were unsatisfactory to many

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Sanibel Inn

6
937 E. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
6th
Romantic
Sanibel Inn
View More Photos
based on 480 hotel reviews
Hotel Terrace and Kiddie Pool were applauded in many reviews
Verdict: Average Quality at an Average Bang for Your Buck
Popular for a romantic getaway

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Beachview Cottages

7
3325 W. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
7th
Romantic
Beachview Cottages
based on 112 hotel reviews
Prior occupants thought the Hotel Dirty Rooms and Tired Rooms could have been better
Guests of Beachview Cottages liked the central location, the attentive and courteous staff and the very nice swimming pool. Yet, they disliked the very old and outdated rooms and the dingy rooms.
Hotel Heated Pool and Kiddie Pool were applauded in many reviews

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25

Sunset Beach Inn

8
3287 W. Gulf Dr., Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
8th
Romantic
Sunset Beach Inn
View More Photos
based on 343 hotel reviews
Just one hour from Southwest Florida International Airport, and directly situated along Sanibel Island’s pristine coastline, Sanibel Sunset Beach Resort offers continental breakfasts, on-site tennis courts, and a variety of bea...  more
Popular for a family vacation
Popular for a romantic getaway

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with

Kona Kai Motel

9
1539 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
9th
Romantic
Kona Kai Motel
based on 177 hotel reviews
Guests of Kona Kai Motel liked the gorgeous pool, the central location and the attentive and courteous staff. Yet, they disliked the tiny rooms, the missing or dysfunctional amenities in the rooms and the not so clean rooms.
Reviewers ranted about the Hotel Dirty Rooms and Small Rooms

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25

Casa Ybel Resort

10
2255 W Gulf Dr, Sanibel Island, 33957 FL
10th
Romantic
Casa Ybel Resort
View More Photos
based on 237 hotel reviews
Popular for a romantic getaway
Guests complained about the Hotel Dirty Rooms and Tired Rooms
Verdict: Average Quality at a Poor Bang for Your Buck

find lowest price
Checkrates126x25
or book with